Canon PIXMA TR8620a vs TS4320: Which One Fits Your Home Tasks?
Choose the TR8620a if you want to replace individual ink colors or regularly scan and copy document stacks through an ADF. The TS4320 uses a two-cartridge setup and a flatbed for originals, fitting lighter jobs where you are comfortable placing each page on the glass.
Published by Pickoryx · Published 2026-10-01
Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Products compared
Product A · ASIN B09TRZLPXP
Canon PIXMA TR8620a (Black, 4451C032)
Last observed offer
$149.00 List Price: $215.99
Per listed package.
Offer eligibility must be confirmed on Amazon.
Checked 2026-10-19 19:07 UTC. Price and availability may change.
Product B · ASIN B0FMBGXC2C
Canon PIXMA TS4320 (White, 7181C002)
Last observed offer
$59.00 List Price: $107.99
Per listed package.
Offer eligibility must be confirmed on Amazon.
Checked 2026-10-19 19:07 UTC. Price and availability may change.
Pickoryx may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through the paid Amazon links on this page, at no added cost to you.
The buying question
Are individual ink tanks and an automatic document feeder useful enough to choose the TR8620a over the TS4320 two-cartridge, flatbed-only workflow?
The TR8620a separates five ink colors and feeds a stack of originals, while the TS4320 combines ink into two cartridges and keeps document handling on the flatbed. Cartridge count does not prove savings, and the feeder does not scan both sides automatically.
Quick verdict
Choose Canon PIXMA TR8620a (Black, 4451C032) if
- You want separate pigment black, dye black, cyan, magenta and yellow tanks so you can replace the tank that runs out.
- You regularly scan or copy a stack: the TR8620a ADF takes up to 20 Letter sheets or five Legal sheets.
Choose Canon PIXMA TS4320 (White, 7181C002) if
- You prefer one black and one combined-color FINE cartridge, and do not need separate color tanks.
- Most originals are single pages and you are comfortable placing them on the flatbed; Canon lists TS4320 ADF capacity as N/A.
When the recommendation changes
- If recurring stacks or Legal originals are part of your routine, the TR8620a ADF is the deciding workflow feature; it does not automatically scan duplex originals.
- If scans are occasional single originals, the TS4320 flatbed may fit without an ADF; its two-cartridge system is not proof of lower ink cost.
- If automatic duplex scanning is required, neither configuration establishes it: the TR8620a ADF cannot scan duplex originals automatically and the TS4320 has no ADF.
The differences that matter
Ink Replacement Workflow
What this changes: The TR8620a supports replacing a particular depleted color tank but requires tracking five supplies. The TS4320 uses two cartridge modules with color combined; that is not evidence of lower cost or higher yield.[1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 8]
Multi Page Scan Workflow
What this changes: Choose the TR8620a when recurring stacks make feeder loading useful; the TS4320 can still make a multi-page file but requires handling pages on the glass individually. The ADF is not automatic duplex scanning.[1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8]
Best for your routine
Replacing only a depleted color in the individual ink set
Best fit: Canon PIXMA TR8620a (Black, 4451C032)
Based on listed features, not comparative testing.
Canon lists five individual TR8620a ink tanks and says to replace the tank whose ink runs out. This is a cartridge-management fit, not a cost or yield claim.
Keeping the cartridge set to one black and one combined-color module
Best fit: Canon PIXMA TS4320 (White, 7181C002)
Based on listed features, not comparative testing.
The TS4320 is specified with two cartridges, black and combined color; the compromise is that color inks are together rather than in separate tanks.
Recurring multi-page or legal-size scanning and copying
Best fit: Canon PIXMA TR8620a (Black, 4451C032)
Based on listed features, not comparative testing.
The TR8620a supports a 20-sheet Letter or five-sheet Legal ADF, but not automatic duplex scanning.
Occasional single-page scans from letter/A4 originals
Best fit: Canon PIXMA TS4320 (White, 7181C002)
Based on listed features, not comparative testing.
The TS4320 documents a letter/A4 flatbed and multi-page PDF support; it fits if manually placing pages is acceptable and an ADF is unnecessary.
Value and trade-offs
One or both observed offers have eligibility conditions, so no unrestricted price difference is shown.
Compare current checkout offers; choose the TR8620a only if its separate ink tanks or ADF workflow matter. The TS4320 lower cartridge count does not establish lower running cost.
No purchase-timing recommendation is made; compare the current seller, condition, bundle and checkout offers.
Limitations
- This comparison uses Canon US specifications and manuals; Pickoryx did not test print quality, scan quality, scan speed, copy speed or ease of use.
- Cartridge configuration does not establish cartridge price, page yield, cost per page or long-term savings.
- The TR8620a ADF is specified for up to 20 Letter plain-paper sheets or five Legal sheets; Canon says it cannot automatically scan duplex originals.
- The TS4320 has a letter/A4 flatbed and ADF capacity N/A; multi-page work therefore requires handling pages individually on the glass.
- Current checkout prices and offers can change; this comparison does not identify a longer-term low or recommend when to buy.
Questions shoppers ask
How many ink cartridges does each printer use?
Canon describes the TR8620a as a five-color individual-ink system: PGI-280 pigment black plus separate CLI-281 dye black, cyan, magenta and yellow tanks. The TS4320 uses two cartridges: PG-295 black and CL-286 color. This is a cartridge-layout difference, not a claim about ink cost or page yield.
Can the TR8620a scan a two-sided stack automatically?
No. Canon’s TR8600-series manual says a duplex original cannot be scanned automatically by the ADF. You can feed a stack, but two-sided originals need to be turned over for another pass.
Can the TS4320 save several pages into one scan file?
Canon lists multi-page PDF support for the TS4320. It has a flatbed scanner and ADF capacity N/A, so you can create a multi-page file while placing each page on the glass individually.
Methodology and sources
The comparison maps documented ink-unit replacement and scanner/ADF loading steps to two home-printer routines. It does not infer real-world print or scan performance, speed, page yield or consumable cost.
A language model assisted with comparing Canon’s published specifications and drafting conditional buying guidance. Pickoryx did not conduct hands-on testing.
View 8 sources
- 1.Canon Support for PIXMA TR8620aCanon U.S.A. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Technical Specifications: ink 1303-1308; feeder/scanner 1323-1333; General > Other Features 1347. Exact support page lists TR8600-series manuals.: Exact US TR8620a specs list five individual tanks (PGI-280 pigment black; CLI-281 dye black/cyan/magenta/yellow), a flatbed plus ADF, 20 Letter or five Legal plain-paper ADF capacity, flatbed maximum 8.5 x 11.7 in and ADF maximum 8.5 x 14 in.
- 2.Canon Inkjet Manuals: TR8600 series: Replacing Ink TanksCanon Inc. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Replacing Procedure steps 2-9; exact TR8620a support page lists TR8600-series user manuals.: The manual says to remove the ink tank whose ink runs out and install its replacement in the position matching the label. TR8620a support page lists this series manual.
- 3.Canon Inkjet Manuals: TR8600 series: Loading Documents in the ADFCanon Inc. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- ADF loading steps 2-5 and duplex-original note; exact TR8620a support page lists TR8600-series manuals.: The manual describes loading originals face up in the ADF and adjusting the width guide; it states a duplex original cannot be scanned automatically by ADF.
- 4.Canon Support for PIXMA TS4320Canon U.S.A. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Technical Specifications > Scan 1268-1275 and Ink Information 1277-1284; exact page links TS4300-series manual listing TS4320.: Exact TS4320 US specs list flatbed scanning up to 8.5 x 11.7 in (A4/Letter), ADF capacity N/A, multi-page PDF and a two-tank hybrid system: PG-295 pigment black and CL-286 dye color (C/M/Y/BK).
- 5.Shop Canon PIXMA TS4320 Wireless Multi-Function Home PrinterCanon U.S.A. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Overview 1904-1907; In the box 1817-1822; Features > two-cartridge system 1935-1938.: Canon says the TS4320 is designed without an ADF, uses a two-cartridge hybrid ink system, and includes PG-295 black and CL-286 color cartridges.
- 6.Canon Inkjet Manuals: TS4300 series: Replacing a FINE CartridgeCanon Inc. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Steps 2-6 and 77-90 for replacing; manual cover model list includes TS4320.: The TS4300-series manual, which lists TS4320 on its model cover, describes replacing FINE cartridges as units and assigns separate left color/right black cartridge positions.
- 7.Canon Inkjet Manuals: TS4300 series: Loading Originals on PlatenCanon Inc. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Steps 1-3; manual cover model list includes TS4320.: The TS4300-series manual lists TS4320 and instructs placing the original on the platen with the cover open, then closing it before scanning or copying.
- 8.Canon Inkjet Manuals: TS4300 series online manualCanon Inc. · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-01 21:35 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Manual cover model list (lines 3-7) explicitly names TS4320 as part of the TS4300 series.: Canon lists TS4320 as an exact model covered by the TS4300-series online manual, bridging the model-specific cartridge-replacement and platen-loading procedures in the related TS4300 manual pages.