Skip to content
Pickoryx

Energizer 46009 vs 58822: Puck Controls and Battery Needs

Choose Energizer 58822 if a separate wall switch is more practical than reaching each puck; its lights automatically turn off after 60 minutes. Choose 46009 if both puck locations will be easy to reach for push-on/off control. For two lights, budget six AA batteries plus the included A23 remote cell for 58822, or six AAA batteries for 46009.

Published by Pickoryx · Published 2026-10-10

Source checked 2026-10-10 20:56 UTC

Products compared

Pickoryx may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through the paid Amazon links on this page, at no added cost to you.

The buying question

Can you reach each light to switch it on and off, and which batteries will you need for the two-light installation?

58822 moves everyday control to a mountable wall switch but adds an A23 switch battery alongside the pucks’ AA cells. 46009 uses push control at the lights and AAA cells.

Quick verdict

When the recommendation changes
  • If the chosen shelf or cabinet makes a puck hard to reach, reconsider push-on/off control before mounting it.
  • If you need the 58822 lights to remain on continuously beyond an hour, account for their automatic shutoff rather than assuming uninterrupted operation.
  • If you already have batteries on hand, check their size: these kits do not use the same cells.

The differences that matter

Control Accessibility

Energizer 58822-T1 Wall Switch Puck Lights, 2 Pack

The two-puck 58822 kit includes a mountable wireless ON/OFF wall switch. Jasco specifies compatibility with lights of the same model number, 58822, within a rated 50-foot range.[1]

Energizer 46009 Push On/Off Puck Lights, 2 Pack

The 46009 two-pack uses push-on/off operation at the lights.[2]

What this changes: Choose 58822 when your planned puck positions make reaching each light inconvenient and a separate switch location works better. Choose 46009 when both lights will be within comfortable reach. The rated range is a manufacturer specification, not a measured result in your room.[1, 2]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Battery Inventory

Energizer 58822-T1 Wall Switch Puck Lights, 2 Pack

Each light requires three AA batteries, not included. For the two-light set, supply six AA cells; the wall switch uses an A23 battery, which is included.[1]

Energizer 46009 Push On/Off Puck Lights, 2 Pack

Each light requires three AAA batteries, not included. Supply six AAA cells for the two-light set.[2]

What this changes: Check your battery supplies separately from your mounting plan: 58822 needs AA cells for the pucks plus an A23 cell for the switch, while 46009 needs AAA cells for its pucks. These quantities do not establish runtime or replacement cost.[1, 2]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Best for your routine

Puck locations are inconvenient to reach, but a nearby switch can be mounted

Best fit: Energizer 58822-T1 Wall Switch Puck Lights, 2 Pack

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

The 58822 kit provides a separate mountable switch. Check the planned location against Jasco’s rated 50-foot range and keep the 60-minute automatic shutoff in mind.

View Energizer 58822-T1 Wall Switch Puck Lights, 2 Pack on AmazonPaid link

Two reachable lights and an existing supply of AAA batteries

Best fit: Energizer 46009 Push On/Off Puck Lights, 2 Pack

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

46009 combines push-on/off operation at the lights with three AAA cells per puck. This fits the specified setup without converting the lighting battery supply to AA.

View Energizer 46009 Push On/Off Puck Lights, 2 Pack on AmazonPaid link

Value and trade-offs

One or both observed offers have eligibility conditions, so no unrestricted price difference is shown.

If 58822 costs more when you shop, judge the difference by whether the separately placed wall switch solves a real reach problem. Compare the complete two-light setup, including batteries you need to supply.

There is not enough verified price history here for a buy-now or wait recommendation.

Limitations

  • This is a control-and-battery comparison, not a brightness, runtime or durability ranking. Published brightness information for 46009 conflicts, so no light-output comparison is made.
  • The 58822 remote is documented for lights of the same model, 58822. Compatibility with 46009 is not established. Its 50-foot range has not been tested here.
  • Battery size and cell count do not establish operating cost, efficiency or time between replacements.
  • The 60-minute automatic shutoff is documented for 58822; the source checked does not settle timer behavior for 46009.

Questions shoppers ask

Can the 58822 wall switch control an existing 46009 puck?

Do not buy it on that assumption. Jasco specifies compatibility with lights of the same model number, 58822; that does not establish control of 46009.

Do I need to buy anything besides the two-pack before installing it?

Supply six AA batteries for the two 58822 lights; its A23 wall-switch battery is included. Supply six AAA batteries for two 46009 lights. Both pages list mounting tape, but 46009 screws are not included if you choose screw mounting.

Methodology and sources

Compared the documented control location and two-light battery requirements, then checked mounting supplies, remote compatibility and the stated automatic shutoff. Manufacturer specifications are not treated as measured performance.

AI assisted with source research, drafting and editing. Pickoryx did not conduct hands-on testing of either light kit.

View 2 sources
  1. 1.Energizer Battery Operated LED Puck Light with Wall Switch Remote, 2 Pack, WhiteJasco · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-10 20:39 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Product title/model, description, Features and Specs/UPC: 58822-T1 and UPC 030878588225; two lights, mountable same-model remote, rated 50-foot range, three AA batteries per light, included A23 switch battery, 60-minute automatic shutoff and mounting hardware.
  2. 2.Energizer Push On/Off Puck Lights, 2 Pack, WhiteJasco · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-10 20:39 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Product title/model, description, Features and Specs/UPC: 46009-T5 and UPC 030878460095 corresponding to base model 46009; two push-on/off lights, three AAA batteries per light, tape included and screws not included.