Skip to content
Pickoryx

Lily 2 vs Venu 3S: When Do You Need Your Phone?

Choose Venu 3S for GPS routes without carrying your phone, or for talking through the watch while your compatible phone stays nearby. Choose Lily 2 if you prefer its smaller case and are happy to carry the phone for GPS and use it for conversation. Lily 2 can still record an activity without GPS and accept or decline calls on a connected phone.

Published by Pickoryx · Published 2026-10-09

Source checked 2026-10-09 07:37 UTC

Products compared

Pickoryx may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through the paid Amazon links on this page, at no added cost to you.

The buying question

Do you need GPS route recording with the phone left behind, conversation through the watch with the phone nearby, or neither?

Lily 2 has the smaller specified case; Venu 3S adds phone-independent GPS recording and paired-phone watch conversation in a 41 mm case.

Quick verdict

When to skip: You need to make and receive phone calls while your phone is left behind.
When the recommendation changes
  • Always carrying the phone removes the phone-free GPS reason to choose Venu 3S, but it does not remove the call-audio difference.
  • If you leave the phone behind and also expect phone calls, neither documented calling workflow meets that requirement.

The differences that matter

Phone Independent Route Recording

Garmin Lily 2 (Cream Gold/Coconut Silicone)

For GPS data on walks, runs or bike rides, keep the phone in range, open Garmin Connect and allow it to always access location. Without the phone connection, you can continue the activity, but GPS data is not recorded.[3, 4]

Garmin Venu 3S (41 mm, Soft Gold/French Gray Silicone)

Records outdoor GPS activities using the watch’s satellite receiver. Select a GPS-enabled activity, go outdoors and wait for satellite acquisition before starting the timer; the phone does not supply the GPS signal.[6, 2]

What this changes: Choose Venu 3S if leaving the phone behind must still leave you with a GPS route. Lily 2 suits carrying the phone for that purpose, or accepting an activity without GPS data.[3, 4, 6, 2]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Paired Phone Conversation Routing

Garmin Lily 2 (Cream Gold/Coconut Silicone)

The watch can accept or decline a call on the connected phone; use that phone to speak to the caller.[5]

Garmin Venu 3S (41 mm, Soft Gold/French Gray Silicone)

With a compatible phone connected by Bluetooth, you can make and take calls through the watch. Setup uses Garmin Connect and phone Bluetooth settings; enable Call Audio for watch conversation. This is not standalone cellular calling.[6, 8]

What this changes: If the phone stays nearby but you want to leave it in your bag during a conversation, choose Venu 3S. If taking the phone out to speak is fine, Lily 2’s call controls may be enough.[5, 6, 8]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Best for your routine

Neither phone-free GPS nor watch conversation is needed

Best fit: Garmin Lily 2 (Cream Gold/Coconut Silicone)

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

Choose Lily 2 if its smaller specified case is your preference and speaking on the phone is acceptable.

View Garmin Lily 2 (Cream Gold/Coconut Silicone) on AmazonPaid link

Value and trade-offs

One or both observed offers have eligibility conditions, so no unrestricted price difference is shown.

Compare current offers. If Venu 3S costs more, paying extra makes sense only if you will use phone-free GPS recording or paired-phone watch conversation; the smaller Lily 2 may otherwise fit your priorities.

There is not enough verified price history here for a buy-now or wait recommendation.

Limitations

  • These are documented capabilities, not hands-on results. GPS accuracy, call quality and connection reliability were not compared.
  • This comparison covers the standard Lily 2 and 41 mm Venu 3S variants named above. Lily 2 Active, Lily 2 Classic and the larger Venu 3 are outside its scope.
  • Phone model, software, Bluetooth connection and required permissions still matter. Third-party calling apps and voice-assistant services are outside this comparison.

Questions shoppers ask

If I always carry my phone, is Venu 3S still useful?

Yes, if you want to speak through the watch rather than take out the phone. That benefit is separate from recording a GPS route without a phone. If you want neither, consider whether Lily 2’s smaller case better matches your preference.

Does an iPhone meet the same requirements as Android?

Check Garmin’s current compatibility page for your phone. At the fact check, Garmin Connect required iOS 18.2 or later, or Android 9 or later with native Google Play support; Android Go was unsupported and some phone models had listed exceptions. Those are app requirements, not a promise that every feature works on every phone. On both watches, the documented decline-with-text reply is Android-only; that restriction is separate from ordinary call acceptance and Venu 3S call audio.

Methodology and sources

Matched the named US variants, then checked two situations separately: recording an outdoor GPS activity with the phone absent, and handling a phone call with the phone nearby.

Automation helped organize source material and prepare the comparison.

View 8 sources
  1. 1.Lily 2 US product specifications, 010-02839-00Garmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:27 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • selected model/part/color; Lily specs in browservenufinal_lilyspecs.json: Standard Lily 2, Cream Gold with Coconut silicone band, exact part 010-02839-00; dimensions 35.4 × 35.4 × 10.1 mm.
  2. 2.Venu 3S US product specifications, 010-02785-02Garmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:27 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • selected part/41mm/color; specs in browsercompatinitial_venuspecs.json: Venu 3S, 41 mm, Soft Gold bezel with French Gray case and silicone band, exact part 010-02785-02; GPS and Bluetooth calling listed.
  3. 3.Lily 2: Recording an Activity with Connected GPSGarmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:26 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Recording an Activity with Connected GPS, steps4-6 and note: Phone must stay in range with Garmin Connect open for GPS recording; activity may continue without the connection but without GPS data.
  4. 4.Lily 2: Connected GPSGarmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:26 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Connected GPS: Connected GPS uses the phone antenna and requires location permission set to always share with Garmin Connect.
  5. 5.Lily 2: Receiving an Incoming Phone CallGarmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:25 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Receiving an Incoming Phone Call: Accept/decline controls are available; conversation takes place on the connected phone. Reject-with-text needs a compatible Android phone via Bluetooth.
  6. 6.Venu 3 series US Owner’s ManualGarmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:26 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Starting an Activity (PDF zero-index page 7); Outdoor Activities (page 11); Pairing Your Phone and Calling from the Watch (pages 57–58); Receiving an Incoming Phone Call (page 58); integrated speaker/microphone (page 59).: Watch acquires satellites for outdoor recording. Setup uses Garmin Connect and phone Bluetooth settings. Calling requires a compatible Bluetooth-connected phone; Phone app supports dialing. Integrated microphone/speaker and Android-only text-reply conditions are documented.
  7. 7.Garmin Connect App Compatibility RequirementsGarmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:28 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Apple iOS Requirements; Android Requirements: Current US app requirements: iOS 18.2 or later; Android 9 or later with native Google Play support. Android Go is unsupported; listed phone exceptions require checking. These app minimums do not guarantee every watch feature.
  8. 8.Venu 3 series: Phone and Bluetooth SettingsGarmin · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-09 07:37 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Pair Phone; Call Audio: Pairs with a compatible Bluetooth phone; Call Audio enables or disables call audio on the watch.

Continue comparing