Skip to content
Pickoryx

Hamilton Beach 38531 vs 38560: Covered Pan Meals or Open Griddle Cooking?

Choose Hamilton Beach 38531 for a lidded pan suited to simmering and braising, with washable parts after removing its temperature control. Choose 38560 for an open cast-iron griddle, a grease tray and metal-utensil use, accepting its drying, oiling and reseasoning routine. Neither is established as the better browning or faster-cooking option.

Published by Pickoryx · Published 2026-10-05

Source checked 2026-10-05 22:15 UTC

Products compared

Pickoryx may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through the paid Amazon links on this page, at no added cost to you.

The buying question

Does your cooking call for a pan with a lid or an open griddle, and which after-use care routine will you maintain?

38531 provides a covered nonstick pan with washable parts after temperature-control removal. 38560 provides an open cast-iron cooktop with a grease tray and a drying, oiling and reseasoning routine.

Quick verdict

When to skip: Skip 38531 if you need a dedicated deep fryer or a pan for stovetop or oven use. Skip 38560 if you will not dry, oil and occasionally reseason its cooktop.
When the recommendation changes
  • Your usual recipes need a pan and lid rather than an open cooking surface.
  • You want to use metal utensils or are unwilling to maintain cast-iron seasoning.
  • You need a deep fryer or a removable pan that can also go on a stovetop.

The differences that matter

Covered Pan Meals Or Open Flat Cooking

Hamilton Beach Durathon Electric Skillet 38531

A removable nonstick skillet with a glass lid. Hamilton Beach lists sautéing, stir-frying, simmering and braising among its uses.[1, 2]

Hamilton Beach Professional Cast Iron Electric Griddle 38560

An open, flat cast-iron cooktop with a grease drain over a removable drip tray. Its guide includes griddle foods such as eggs, pancakes and grilled sandwiches.[3, 4]

What this changes: Choose 38531 when the planned meal calls for a pan and lid, such as a simmered or braised dish. Choose 38560 when you want an open flat cooking surface with a grease-collection tray. The recipes overlap; this is a choice of cooking arrangement, not a claim that only one can cook a given ingredient.[1, 2, 3, 4]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Coated Pan Washing Or Seasoned Iron Care

Hamilton Beach Durathon Electric Skillet 38531

Turn the control to MIN, unplug and remove the temperature control, then let the skillet cool completely. The pan, lid and base can be handwashed or dishwasher-washed without the SANI cycle. Rinse and dry; keep the control, cord and plug out of liquid.[1, 2]

Hamilton Beach Professional Cast Iron Electric Griddle 38560

Switch off and unplug, then follow the cast-iron cleanup routine. Thoroughly dry the cooled cooktop and wipe it with a little oil before storage; reseason when needed. Do not soak, air-dry or dishwasher-wash the cast iron. Wipe the electrical base separately without immersing it.[4]

What this changes: 38531 suits someone who wants washable pan parts after detaching the electrical control. 38560 suits someone willing to maintain seasoned cast iron. The different care tasks remain relevant even when either cooking shape would suit dinner; no cleaning-time or lifespan advantage is measured.[1, 2, 4]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Best for your routine

Cooking a meal that calls for a pan and lid

Best fit: Hamilton Beach Durathon Electric Skillet 38531

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

38531 supplies the glass lid and pan format, and the manufacturer lists simmering and braising. Match it to the recipe rather than treating the coating or lid as proof of better results.

View Hamilton Beach Durathon Electric Skillet 38531 on AmazonPaid link

Using metal utensils on an open cast-iron griddle

Best fit: Hamilton Beach Professional Cast Iron Electric Griddle 38560

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

38560 combines the flat cooking surface and grease tray with permission to use metal utensils. This choice includes drying, oiling and occasional reseasoning.

View Hamilton Beach Professional Cast Iron Electric Griddle 38560 on AmazonPaid link

Washing removable pan parts in a dishwasher

Best fit: Hamilton Beach Durathon Electric Skillet 38531

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

Follow the skillet guide: turn to MIN, unplug, remove the temperature control and cool completely. Only the pan, lid and base go in the wash; do not use SANI, and keep the control, cord and plug dry.

View Hamilton Beach Durathon Electric Skillet 38531 on AmazonPaid link

Value and trade-offs

One or both observed offers have eligibility conditions, so no unrestricted price difference is shown.

Pay for the cooking arrangement and upkeep routine you will use. A glass-lidded pan and a seasoned flat cooktop serve different preferences; neither material establishes a flavor, speed or durability return on a higher price.

Price-history evidence is insufficient to recommend buying now or waiting.

Limitations

  • We did not compare heat uniformity, searing, food release, cooking speed, cleaning time or longevity. Coating and cast-iron marketing claims do not establish a performance or chemical-safety winner.
  • Hamilton Beach’s current 38531 product page provides an October 2019 electric-skillet guide whose model table names 38529. The pan, lid, base and detachable-control arrangement matches the product description; check the instructions supplied with your unit if they differ.
  • Cooking-surface dimensions do not establish servings or actual recipe capacity. This comparison does not verify current retailer accessory bundles or promise that every recipe works equally well in both formats.

Questions shoppers ask

Does the skillet’s removable pan also work on the stove or in the oven?

No. The guide provided for 38531 says not to use the skillet or its lid on a range top, in an oven or in a microwave. The griddle’s separate oven procedure is only for reseasoning its removed cast-iron cooktop, without the electrical base.

Which parts of 38531 can go in the dishwasher?

After turning to MIN, unplugging, removing the temperature control and cooling completely, the guide permits washing the pan, lid and base. Do not use the SANI cycle. The temperature control, cord and plug must stay out of water; wipe the control and cord and dry them as directed.

Does preseasoned 38560 cast iron need further care?

Yes. Dry the cooktop thoroughly after cleaning, wipe it with a little oil before storage and reseason when needed. Do not soak the cast iron, leave it to air-dry or put it in a dishwasher. Keep the electrical base out of water.

Is 38531 intended for deep-frying?

No. Its linked guide explicitly says it is not intended for deep-frying. The manufacturer’s listed pan uses include sautéing, stir-frying, simmering and braising.

Methodology and sources

We compared the cooking formats, permitted utensils, component washing boundaries and cast-iron upkeep. The source edition and model-label limitation for the skillet guide are disclosed.

AI assisted with reading the documentation and organizing this comparison.

View 4 sources
  1. 1.Hamilton Beach Durathon Electric Skillet, 38531Hamilton Beach · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-05 22:10 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Model 38531; Details; Support: Describes a removable nonstick pan with a glass lid for tasks including simmering and braising. Identifies the washable pan, lid and base after cord removal and provides the use-and-care guide.
  2. 2.Hamilton Beach Electric Skillet: Use and Care, 2019Hamilton Beach · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-05 22:11 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • English pages 2 and 4–6; October 2019 edition, 840284601: Hamilton Beach provides this October 2019 guide through the 38531 page; its model table names 38529. It requires temperature-control removal and cooling before washing. The pan, lid and base are dishwasher safe without the SANI cycle; the control, cord and plug must stay out of liquid.
  3. 3.Hamilton Beach Professional Cast Iron Electric Griddle, 38560Hamilton Beach · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-05 22:10 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Model 38560; Features and Details: Describes the removable preseasoned cast-iron cooktop, metal-utensil compatibility and grease drain with removable tray. The tray is top-rack dishwasher safe.
  4. 4.Hamilton Beach 38560: Use and CareHamilton Beach · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-05 18:57 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • English pages 4–7; model table on page 24: Explains open flat-cooktop use, cooling before tray removal, thorough drying and oiling, and reseasoning the removed cast iron. The cooktop must not be soaked or dishwasher-washed, and the electrical base must not be immersed.

Continue comparing