Skip to content
Pickoryx

HP Envy 6155 vs Smart Tank 5003: Which Fits Your Home Printing?

Choose by supply routine and duplex workflow. HP documents HP 68 cartridges and automatic duplex on the Envy; for the Smart Tank 5000/5100 series, HP documents a refillable ink system, included page allowances and manual duplex. HP's exact 5003 material identifies product number 9B2D3A, but verify the exact US retail-box terms before purchase.

Published by Pickoryx · Published 2026-10-08

Source checked 2026-10-08 11:16 UTC

Products compared

Pickoryx may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through the paid Amazon links on this page, at no added cost to you.

The buying question

Would replaceable cartridges and automatic two-sided printing fit better, or would a refillable ink-tank workflow with HP's published included-page allowance?

The Envy uses two HP 68 cartridges and automates duplex printing; the Smart Tank uses refillable bottles and requires manual duplex steps. This is a feature-fit comparison, not a measured running-cost or print-quality verdict.

Quick verdict

Choose HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer if

  • You want automatic two-sided printing rather than manually turning pages.
  • You are comfortable replacing HP 68 cartridges; HP currently advertises a three-month Instant Ink offer on its US Envy 6155 product page, but verify that offer and its subscription terms for the exact seller and package.
View HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer on AmazonPaid link

Choose HP Smart Tank 5003 All-in-One Printer if

  • You prefer a refillable bottle-and-tank supply routine and can work with manual duplex printing.
  • You expect to use a substantial share of the included ink; HP's US Smart Tank 5000/5100 series page lists 6,000 black and 6,000 color pages, with actual yield varying by use.
View HP Smart Tank 5003 All-in-One Printer on AmazonPaid link
When to skip: You want a monochrome laser printer or a toner-based system; both choices here are color inkjet all-in-ones.
When the recommendation changes
  • Your duplex routine changes: frequent two-sided jobs favor the Envy's documented automatic duplex, while occasional duplex may make the Smart Tank's manual process acceptable.
  • Your supply preference changes from swapping cartridges to refilling bottles; no total-cost winner is established here.

The differences that matter

Ink Supply And Replenishment Workflow

HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer

Two HP 68 setup cartridges, black and tri-color; replacement cartridge options are listed on the HP US product page.[1]

HP Smart Tank 5003 All-in-One Printer

Refillable tank/bottle design for Smart Tank 5003 (product number 9B2D3A); HP's US 5000/5100 series page lists 6,000 black and 6,000 color pages included. Actual yield and exact US retail-box contents are not established by the opened 5003 page.[2, 3]

What this changes: A buyer chooses between replacing cartridges and replenishing tanks from bottles. Included page allowances and offer terms should not be translated into a cross-model total-cost result.[1, 2, 3]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Two Sided And Document Workflow

HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer

Automatic two-sided printing; print, copy and scan; flatbed scanner.[1]

HP Smart Tank 5003 All-in-One Printer

Manual two-sided printing with driver support; print, copy and scan; flatbed-only scanner on the exact 5003/9B2D3A specification.[2, 3]

What this changes: Automatic duplex removes the manual page-turning step; neither source set establishes a real-world print-quality or speed advantage.[1, 2, 3]

Best fit: HP Envy 6155 All-in-One PrinterView HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer on AmazonPaid link

Best for your routine

A home buyer who regularly prints two-sided documents and wants the printer to handle page turning

Best fit: HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

HP specifies automatic duplex on the Envy 6155; the Smart Tank series uses manual duplex. This is a workflow fit, not a speed or print-quality claim.

View HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer on AmazonPaid link

A home buyer who prefers bottle refills and accepts manual duplex

Best fit: HP Smart Tank 5003 All-in-One Printer

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

HP documents refillable tanks and included page allowances for the Smart Tank family; compare your actual printing pattern before treating the allowance as useful value.

View HP Smart Tank 5003 All-in-One Printer on AmazonPaid link

Value and trade-offs

One or both observed offers have eligibility conditions, so no unrestricted price difference is shown.

If one option carries a higher live price, weigh its preferred supply system and duplex workflow against that difference; this comparison does not calculate payback or total ownership cost.

Historical price data was not assessed; this comparison reflects current offer snapshots only, so it offers no timing guidance.

Limitations

  • HP's US Smart Tank page describes the 5000/5100 series, while HP's opened exact 5003 specification page is region-specific. Confirm the exact US listing's product number, included bottle/printhead package and offer terms before purchase.
  • HP's 'up to three years' ink language is a usage-based estimate, not a guaranteed calendar lifespan or a matched cost-per-page comparison. HP says actual yield varies with page content and other factors.
  • The Envy Instant Ink offer is time- and package-sensitive. Check enrollment, free-trial end date, recurring plan terms and cancellation details before relying on it.
  • No hands-on, controlled print-quality, speed, reliability or lifetime-cost comparison was conducted. Flatbed specifications do not alone establish whether a specific workflow supports an automatic document feeder.

Questions shoppers ask

Does the Smart Tank 5003 really include three years of ink?

HP describes up to three years for eligible Smart Tank offers, but its US family page ties the claim to stated monthly use and included page totals; it says actual yield varies and some ink is used during setup. Treat the page totals as the useful published reference and verify the exact US package before buying.

Can both printers scan, copy and print on both sides?

HP lists print, copy and scan for both. The Envy 6155 has automatic duplex; HP lists manual duplex for the Smart Tank 5000/5100 series. Both specifications describe flatbed scanning. The Smart Tank exact-model page says flatbed only; check the Envy's document-feed workflow if you need to scan stacks.

Is Instant Ink included with every Envy 6155 listing?

HP's US store currently advertises a three-month Instant Ink offer with product number C2WR7A#B1H. HP says automatic delivery requires an eligible internet-connected printer, a valid payment method, an email address and delivery service in your area. The exact marketplace offer and post-trial plan terms still need checking; verify before counting the trial.

Methodology and sources

Compared exact HP product identifiers and published cartridge/refill and duplex/document workflows. Smart Tank family-level US claims are labeled as family claims; no measured performance or total-cost winner is inferred.

Research assistance organized manufacturer-published specifications; it did not physically test either printer.

View 3 sources
  1. 1.HP Envy 6155 All-in-One Printer with 3 months free Instant Ink, AI-capableHP US Store · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-08 11:16 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Product identity, Instant Ink offer and product number (lines 31–65); features, cartridges and duplex/scan specifications (lines 258–323, 350–361, 403–405, 449–470, 557–569); Instant Ink delivery conditions (lines 616–619).: Identifies C2WR7A#B1H; lists two HP 68 cartridges, setup cartridge page yields, automatic duplex, print/copy/scan, flatbed scanner, USB/Wi-Fi, and a current three-month Instant Ink offer. The offer is time-sensitive and exact marketplace-package terms are not asserted.
  2. 2.HP Smart Tank Printers – Refillable Ink Tank PrintersHP US · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-08 11:16 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • 5000/5100 series comparison (lines 52–77), refill process (lines 155–158), included-ink disclaimer and usage conditions (lines 239–254).: US HP page explicitly groups the Smart Tank 5000/5100 series and lists 6,000 black/6,000 color included pages, manual duplex, and a flatbed scanner. HP's usage footnote describes qualifying page totals/monthly use for the three-year estimate and says actual yield varies; it is a family-level statement, not Amazon-ASIN-specific box proof.
  3. 3.HP Smart Tank 5003 All-in-One Printer (9B2D3A) – Technical specificationsHP Romania · Official support · Source checked 2026-10-08 11:16 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Exact model/product number (lines 21–22), duplex and connectivity (lines 34, 42–45), scanner type (lines 65–70), included component listing and supply type (lines 95–98).: Official HP page identifies Smart Tank 5003 with product number 9B2D3A and lists print/copy/scan, manual duplex, flatbed-only scanning, and refillable ink-bottle supply. Its listed box configuration is regional and is not represented as the US Amazon bundle.

Continue comparing