Lodge L9OG3 vs. L8SGP3: Compare Surface, Fit and Handling
Both are 10.5-inch seasoned cast iron, but Lodge describes different formats: a round griddle for examples such as pancakes and tortillas, and a square grill pan with raised ridges. The square pan is listed heavier and longer overall, while both need the same hand-wash, dry and oil routine. Choose by the documented surface format and your actual setup; nominal size does not prove cooking area or performance.
Published by Pickoryx · Published 2026-10-20
Source checked 2026-10-20 20:04 UTC
Products compared
Product A · ASIN B00008GKDN
Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle (L9OG3)
Last observed offer
$24.90
Per listed package.
Offer eligibility must be confirmed on Amazon.
Checked 2026-10-22 08:20 UTC. Price and availability may change.
Product B · ASIN B0000CF66W
Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan (L8SGP3)
Last observed offer
$24.90
Per listed package.
Offer eligibility must be confirmed on Amazon.
Checked 2026-10-22 07:45 UTC. Price and availability may change.
Pickoryx may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through the paid Amazon links on this page, at no added cost to you.
The buying question
Should you choose the round L9OG3 griddle or square L8SGP3 grill pan for the foods you make, your cooktop and storage, and how you handle cast iron?
The L9OG3 is Lodge’s round griddle and has a lower listed weight; the L8SGP3 is a square grill pan with raised grill ridges and a loop handle, but has a higher listed weight and a longer listed overall length. Both require hand washing, full drying and oiling.
Quick verdict
Choose Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle (L9OG3) if
- You want Lodge’s round griddle format for its listed pancake or tortilla uses and the lower listed weight suits your lifting routine.
- The round griddle’s listed outer dimensions fit your cooktop and storage better after you measure them.
Choose Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan (L8SGP3) if
- You specifically want the square grill pan’s documented raised ridges.
- The pictured loop handle is useful to your transfer routine and the higher listed weight and longer overall length work for you.
When the recommendation changes
- Your specific burner, oven, cabinet or food requires a usable cooking-area measurement; the two pages do not publish matching usable-area dimensions.
The differences that matter
Cooking Setup And Fit
Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle (L9OG3)
Lodge identifies the L9OG3 as a 10.5-inch round seasoned cast-iron griddle and names pancakes and tortillas as example uses.[1]
Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan (L8SGP3)
Lodge identifies the L8SGP3 as a 10.5-inch square cast-iron grill pan and explicitly lists raised grill ridges.[2]
What this changes: Choose by the cooking format you want: A is Lodge’s round griddle with pancake/tortilla examples; B is the grill pan whose raised ridges are explicitly documented. This is feature-fit guidance, not a claim about cooking results or about an undocumented feature being absent from A.[1, 2]
Cooking Setup And Fit
Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle (L9OG3)
The round L9OG3 is listed at 10.62 inches wide and 15.87 inches long including its handle.[1]
Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan (L8SGP3)
The square L8SGP3 is listed at 10.5 inches wide and 17.06 inches long including handles. Lodge’s drawing separately labels 10 inches of cooking-surface length and an 8.12-inch flat-bottom width.[2]
What this changes: Check the outer measurements against your appliance and storage. These are not matching usable-area measurements, so they do not establish which pan holds more food or fits a particular burner better.[1, 2]
Care And Handling Workflow
Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle (L9OG3)
Lodge lists 4.65 pounds; product images show a long handle. The product page says hand wash, dry, oil.[1]
Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan (L8SGP3)
Lodge lists 7.33 pounds; product images show a long handle and loop handle. The product page says hand wash, dry, oil.[2]
What this changes: Compare the listed weights and pictured grip points with how you lift and store cookware; they do not prove comfort or ease. Both need the same documented cast-iron care routine.[1, 2, 3]
Care And Handling Workflow
What this changes: Neither model offers a documented cleanup shortcut; avoid soaking and dishwasher use for both.[1, 2, 3]
Best for your routine
A buyer seeking a round griddle for Lodge’s named pancake/tortilla examples and who values the lower listed weight
Best fit: Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle (L9OG3)
Based on listed features, not comparative testing.
Lodge identifies A as the round griddle and gives pancakes and tortillas as example uses; it lists A at 4.65 pounds versus 7.33 pounds for B. No cooking-performance result is inferred.
A buyer who specifically wants a square grill pan with documented raised grill ridges
Best fit: Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan (L8SGP3)
Based on listed features, not comparative testing.
Lodge explicitly lists raised grill ridges for B. This supports choosing the feature, not a claim that food cooks better or that A lacks a similar feature.
Value and trade-offs
One or both observed offers have eligibility conditions, so no unrestricted price difference is shown.
If either exact-model offer costs more, the buyer-facing reasons to weigh are the preferred cooking format, listed weight and grip setup; compare current offers for the exact models.
There is not enough price history to recommend buying now or waiting; compare the current offers for these exact models.
Limitations
- The manufacturer pages do not provide matching usable cooking-area dimensions for both pans. The square pan’s drawing gives a cooking-surface length and flat-bottom width, while the round page lists outer dimensions; do not treat these as a direct area or capacity comparison.
- No controlled side-by-side cooking or handling test was performed, so this comparison does not rank heat distribution, cooking results, ridge marks, release or comfort.
Questions shoppers ask
Does the square grill pan have more usable cooking area because both are called 10.5 inches?
The published dimensions do not answer that. Lodge lists outer dimensions for the round griddle and gives some separate flat-bottom/cooking-surface dimensions for the square grill pan, but they are not comparable measures of usable area. Check the actual cooking space you need before buying.
What is the clearest documented cooking-surface distinction?
Lodge explicitly lists raised grill ridges on the L8SGP3 and describes the L9OG3 as a round griddle with pancake and tortilla examples. That supports choosing by the cooking format you want, not a promise about the food result.
Do they need different cleanup?
No difference is documented: Lodge says hand wash, dry and oil for both. Its care guide recommends warm soapy water, complete drying and a thin layer of oil, and warns against soaking and dishwasher use.
Methodology and sources
Compared Lodge’s L9OG3 and L8SGP3 product pages for their stated formats, dimensions, listed weight, compatible cooking setups and handle images, then checked Lodge’s cast-iron care guide. No cooking or usability conclusions were drawn from those specifications.
AI-assisted research organized manufacturer specifications and care guidance; Pickoryx did not cook with or test either pan.
View 3 sources
- 1.Round Cast Iron Griddle | Shop All Sizes Online | Lodge Cast IronLodge Cast Iron · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-20 20:04 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- 10.5 Inch Round Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle / L9OG3; product title and model code, dimensions, listed weight, stated uses, stovetop/oven/grill/campfire compatibility, and hand-wash/dry/oil care.: Identifies the 10.5-inch round L9OG3; Lodge lists pancakes and tortillas as example uses, lists any stovetop including induction plus oven/grill/campfire compatibility, 10.62-inch width, 15.87-inch length including handle and 4.65-pound weight. The page says hand wash, dry, oil.
- 2.10.5 Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan | Shop Online | Lodge Cast IronLodge Cast Iron · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-20 20:04 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- 10.5 Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan / L8SGP3; product title and model code, raised grill ridges, dimensions/dimensional drawing, listed weight, compatibility, product image and care.: Identifies the 10.5-inch square L8SGP3 cast-iron grill pan and explicitly lists raised grill ridges. Lodge lists stovetop including induction, oven, grill and campfire compatibility, 10.5-inch total width, 17.06-inch total length including handles, 7.33-pound weight. Its dimensional-drawing captions separately give a 10-inch cooking-surface length, 8.12-inch flat-bottom width, and 0.31-inch distance between grill lines. Page says hand wash, dry, oil.
- 3.How to Clean – Lodge Cast IronLodge Cast Iron · Official support · Source checked 2026-10-20 20:04 UTC
Evidence used on this page
- Clean your Lodge Cast Iron Cookware in three simple steps; wash, dry, oil; soaking and dishwasher FAQs.: Lodge advises washing with warm, soapy water, drying completely, then applying a thin layer of oil. Its FAQ says not to soak cast iron or put it in a dishwasher.