Skip to content
Pickoryx

OXO Contoured Pepper Grinder vs. Cole & Mason Derwent Set: Which Fits Your Seasoning Setup?

The OXO is a single pepper grinder with a five-level sliding tab. The Cole & Mason Derwent selection is a salt-and-pepper set: its manufacturer describes six pepper settings and three salt settings. Choose by whether you need one mill or both; the published settings do not show which mill produces better pepper.

Published by Pickoryx · Published 2026-10-15

Source checked 2026-10-15 22:35 UTC

Products compared

Pickoryx may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through the paid Amazon links on this page, at no added cost to you.

The buying question

Do you need a single pepper grinder, or do you also want a matching salt mill, and which documented grind-setting control suits your preferences?

The OXO is one pepper grinder with a five-position sliding tab; the Derwent offer is a two-mill salt-and-pepper set with separate published grind-setting counts for pepper and salt.

Quick verdict

When the recommendation changes
  • If you only need pepper, the Derwent set's extra salt mill may be unnecessary; if you want both seasonings in one set, that extra mill becomes relevant. The grind-setting counts describe options, not grind quality.

The differences that matter

Grind Setting Interface

OXO Good Grips Contoured Pepper Grinder

Five grind levels from fine to coarse, adjusted by a sliding tab.[1]

Cole & Mason Derwent Salt & Pepper Mill Set

Six preset pepper levels and three salt levels; turn the Grind Select collar to adjust.[2]

What this changes: The listed setting counts and controls offer different ways to select a grind; they do not measure the resulting pepper or salt.[1, 2]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Single Pepper Mill Vs Salt And Pepper Set

OXO Good Grips Contoured Pepper Grinder

Model 11312500 is presented as one pepper grinder.[1]

Cole & Mason Derwent Salt & Pepper Mill Set

The H59408GUSA Salt & Pepper set lists one salt mill and one pepper mill.[2]

What this changes: Whether the buyer wants one pepper mill or a matching pair is a separate purchase question from the grind-setting control.[1, 2]

The better fit depends on your priorities

Best for your routine

You want one pepper grinder and do not need a salt mill in the same set.

Best fit: OXO Good Grips Contoured Pepper Grinder

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

The OXO product page is for a pepper grinder; the Derwent selection is a salt-and-pepper set.

View OXO Good Grips Contoured Pepper Grinder on AmazonPaid link

You want a salt mill and pepper mill together.

Best fit: Cole & Mason Derwent Salt & Pepper Mill Set

Based on listed features, not comparative testing.

The Derwent selection lists one salt mill and one pepper mill as its gift-set contents.

View Cole & Mason Derwent Salt & Pepper Mill Set on AmazonPaid link

Value and trade-offs

One or both observed offers have eligibility conditions, so no unrestricted price difference is shown.

The extra salt mill matters only if you want both mills. Do not infer a price premium or per-mill value without comparing current offers.

Price is not assessed here; check current offers before purchasing.

Limitations

  • The comparison uses published product information, not a Pickoryx hands-on test. It does not assess grind consistency, speed, effort, durability, or taste.
  • Current prices and any per-mill value comparison are not evaluated here.
  • The OXO product page identifies one pepper-grinder model; the Cole & Mason selection compared here is specifically the H59408GUSA Salt & Pepper set, not the brand's separate salt-only or pepper-only variants.

Questions shoppers ask

Does the Derwent set have nine pepper settings?

No. Cole & Mason describes six preset settings for pepper and three for salt; the total refers to the two different mills, not nine pepper settings.

Methodology and sources

Compared the exact US model pages for documented grind-setting controls and the listed salt-and-pepper set contents. Retail product pages were checked for exact selected-model and package identity, not used to support product-performance claims.

AI-assisted research summarized the opened manufacturer pages and checked the exact selected-model records; no automated or hands-on grinding test was performed.

View 2 sources
  1. 1.Contoured Mess-Free Pepper GrinderOXO · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-15 22:34 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Product Details and Features; Specifications (SKU 11312500): Identifies the USA product as SKU 11312500 and describes a manual pepper grinder with five fine-to-coarse settings selected by a sliding tab; the Features section describes top-side grinding and the upside-down refill position.
  2. 2.Cole & Mason Derwent Salt & Pepper Mills – Adjustable Grind Select, 190mm (7½")Cole & Mason USA · Official specifications · Source checked 2026-10-15 22:34 UTC
    Evidence used on this page
    • Product heading/model H59408GUSA; Specifications > Gift Set Contents; Grind Select and FAQ sections: The US page identifies H59408GUSA and its Salt & Pepper selection; it lists one salt mill and one pepper mill in the set, describes Grind Select, six preset pepper levels and three salt levels, and turning the collar to adjust.